BMC-84 vs BMC-85: Which Freight Broker Financial Security Should You Choose?
FMCSA requires all freight brokers to post $75,000 in financial security. You can do this with a BMC-84 surety bond (pay a premium to a surety company) or a BMC-85 trust fund (deposit $75K in an irrevocable trust). 95% of brokers choose BMC-84 because it preserves working capital.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| BMC-84 Surety Bond | BMC-85 Trust Fund | |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | $0 (premium only) | $75,000 deposit |
| Annual cost | $900-$3,500 premium | Trustee fees $250-$1,000/year |
| Credit check required | Yes (affects premium) | No |
| Cash flow impact | Minimal | $75K locked up |
| Renewal | Annual premium renewal | Stays in place indefinitely |
| Freed capital on exit | None (premiums non-refundable) | Full $75K returned minus fees |
| Used by | ~95% of brokers | ~5% of brokers |
Which Is Right for You?
Choose BMC-84 Surety Bond if:
- You have decent credit (650+) and want to preserve working capital
- You don't want to tie up $75,000 in a trust
- You can afford the annual premium
Choose BMC-85 Trust Fund if:
- You have poor credit and can't get a BMC-84 at reasonable rates
- You have $75K sitting idle you don't need for operations
- You want to avoid annual renewal decisions
The Most Common Mistake
Waiting until the BMC-84 premium renewal to shop. Premiums often increase 20-40% on renewal if you've had any claims, and surety companies can refuse renewal altogether. Shop your bond 60 days before renewal, not 30. If you have any claims or credit issues, start the shopping process 90 days out.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does a BMC-84 bond cost?
BMC-84 premiums range $900-$3,500/year depending on credit, business age, and financials. New brokers with credit scores below 650 pay the high end. Established brokers with 700+ credit pay $900-$1,500.
Can I switch from BMC-85 to BMC-84 later?
Yes. File new BMC-84 paperwork with FMCSA, wait for approval, then close the BMC-85 trust. You get your $75K back (minus any fees) when the trust closes. Timing matters — don't close the trust before the new bond is accepted.
What happens if a motor carrier files a claim against my BMC-84?
The surety investigates. If valid, the surety pays the claim (up to $75K total across all claims) and then pursues you for reimbursement. You are personally liable for the claim amount. This is why credit and financial health matter for BMC-84 pricing.
Do I need both BMC-84 and BMC-85?
No. You need one or the other — never both. FMCSA requires $75K in financial security, and either option satisfies that requirement.
Still Not Sure Which You Need?
Full Coverage reviews your operation and places the right mix of coverages. No guesswork. We compare 30+ A-rated carriers to find the best fit.